News

MacKenzie: Sun would have "come close to being shut down" if got Milly Dowler story wrong

09/01/2012

Newspaper
✕ Press claim

✓ The truth

Reach
Up to
people misled
Help us fight back

Join 71,384 others who are taking action to share the truth & raise standards in the press

1. Share the truth
Post this rebuttal on social media
2. Fund the fightback
Help us challenge more stories like this
Donate
3. Tell your MP
Send a ready-written email in 30 seconds
Email your MP

Kelvin MacKenzie has told the Leveson Inquiry that the Sun would have come "very, very, very close to being shut down" if they had "got the Milly Dowler story wrong".

The former Sun editor was referring to a series of Guardian articles stating that private investigator Glenn Mulcaire was responsible for deleting messages from the missing teenager’s voicemail while working for the News of the World.

Lord Justice Leveson reacted by saying it was an "interesting assertion" to call the Guardian stories "completely wrong".

MacKenzie added: "People view the Sun at the bottom of the pile and for as long as it exists I think they view papers like the Guardian as the top of the pile."

He also referred to "snobbery" in the industry and press standards are "really defined by outcome, not by the income".

Sally Dowler told the Inquiry in November 2011 that her family had been given false hope after voicemail messages were deleted from her daughter’s phone, believing they could have been accessed by Milly.

She said: "I rang her phone and it clicked through on to her voicemail and I just jumped and said: 'She’s picked up her phone. Bob, she’s alive'. When we heard about the hacking that was the first thing I thought."

The Guardian published a correction on 13 December last year stating that "new evidence" had led the Metropolitan police to conclude the original theory to be incorrect and that "while the News of the World hacked Milly Dowler’s phone the newspaper is unlikely to have been responsible for the deletion of a set of emails from the phone that caused her parents to have false hope that she was alive". A footnote was appended to 37 stories dating from July to November 2011 on the Guardian website.

Hacked Off is funded by supporters, not newspaper owners. Help us take this to Parliament: give £10 a month.

Give £10 a month

Download the full report:

Download report

Queries: campaign@hackinginquiry.org

related Posts

Coverage of Professor Arday was not legitimate: the letter The Times refused to publish
Guest blog: Professor Paul Wragg replies to the letter published in The Times on 25 August defending the press coverage of Professor Jason Arday. The Times declined to publish his reply. We publish it here in full.
8/28/26
News
Defensive, evasive & hypocritical: The press reaction to the death of Jason Arday
The reaction of national newspapers to the death of Professor Jason Arday has exposed a brittle defensiveness at the heart of the press, and a determination to remain outside any meaningful accountability.
8/26/26
News
When media abuse of academics becomes the norm in HE
Following the death of Jason Arday, Corinne Fowler writes on the toll of media abuse on academics and what universities must do to protect their staff.
8/19/26
News
IPSO ties itself in knots over Telegraph complaint
Media lawyer Jonathan Coad complained to IPSO about a Telegraph article claiming Hacked Off wants "state control" of the press. IPSO's response contradicted itself within the space of a few paragraphs.
8/14/26
News