News

Mr Justice Saunders begins three-day summing up in phone hacking trial

04/06/2014

Martin Hickman

Newspaper
✕ Press claim

✓ The truth

Reach
Up to
people misled
Help us fight back

Join 71,384 others who are taking action to share the truth & raise standards in the press

1. Share the truth
Post this rebuttal on social media
2. Fund the fightback
Help us challenge more stories like this
Donate
3. Tell your MP
Send a ready-written email in 30 seconds
Email your MP

Jurors in Court 12 of the Old Bailey will have to determine three key issues about phone hacking at the News of the World: how much was there, when - and who knew?, the judge said today.

Beginning his three-day summing up in the phone hacking trial, Mr Justice John Saunders said the jury should disregard all extraneous matters when deciding whether the seven defendants were guilty or not guilty.

Addressing the eight woman and three men directly, Mr Justice Saunders said they should not feel sorry for the defendants, even though they may have had difficulties as a result of the allegations against them.

Andy Coulson, for instance, the judge said, had had a "dramatic fall" from his high-profile life, while Rebekah Brooks had received many hurtful and harsh comments in the media and elsewhere.

Mr Justice Saunders said: "Do not let your judgement be affected because some of them enjoyed a lifestyle like you or I can only dream about."

They are friends of stars who most of us only get to watch on the cinema or the football pitch. But do not envy their success, or be dazzled by it."

The judge continued: "Everyone in this country gets the same fair trial as everybody else."

He said the jury should think because of the humour sometimes displayed by the lawyers and the judge himself that the case or the charges were not serious, because they were."

It is simply that without humour the seven months would have been even more intolerable than we found them," the judge said.

He directed the jury that they could take into account the silence of five of the defendants when interviewed by the police they also had to weight up the fact that they were following the advice of their lawyers - which had not been disclosed to the court.

While some of the defendant's factual errors - such as Rebekah Brooks's PA Cheryl Carter telling he police her boss was away on a fitness "boot camp" at the time some boxes were removed from News International's archive - could be entirely innocent, it was also the case that sometimes defendants lied to protect themselves, he said.

Turning to phone hacking, the judge said there was no doubt that the privacy of individuals had been violated by the News of the World's practice of phone hacking. He mentioned two individuals whose messages had been eavesdropped for no good reason: Hannah Pawlby, advisor to Home Secretary Charles Clarke - whom the paper wrongly suspected was having an affair with the Labour politician - and Laura Rooney, who had been hacked only because she shared a surname with a famous footballer.

Mr Justice Saunders said: "Everyone is agreed that phone hacking went on at the News of the World: the issues are how much, when, and who knew about it."

His summing up continues. All defendants deny the charges.

Hacked Off is funded by supporters, not newspaper owners. Help us take this to Parliament: give £10 a month.

Give £10 a month

Download the full report:

Download report

Queries: campaign@hackinginquiry.org

related Posts

Coverage of Professor Arday was not legitimate: the letter The Times refused to publish
Guest blog: Professor Paul Wragg replies to the letter published in The Times on 25 August defending the press coverage of Professor Jason Arday. The Times declined to publish his reply. We publish it here in full.
8/28/26
News
Defensive, evasive & hypocritical: The press reaction to the death of Jason Arday
The reaction of national newspapers to the death of Professor Jason Arday has exposed a brittle defensiveness at the heart of the press, and a determination to remain outside any meaningful accountability.
8/26/26
News
When media abuse of academics becomes the norm in HE
Following the death of Jason Arday, Corinne Fowler writes on the toll of media abuse on academics and what universities must do to protect their staff.
8/19/26
News
IPSO ties itself in knots over Telegraph complaint
Media lawyer Jonathan Coad complained to IPSO about a Telegraph article claiming Hacked Off wants "state control" of the press. IPSO's response contradicted itself within the space of a few paragraphs.
8/14/26
News