News

News

"Public interest standard in law is not engaged merely by "printing something the public were interested in” - Judge

03/03/2015

News International gave police investigating alleged misconduct by their staff access to over 23 million internal emails a court was told today.

Geoffrey Cox QC, who is defending the Sun's deputy editor Geoffrey Webster told a jury at London's Old Bailey that the millions of emails were uploaded to a database and police then carried out a "keyword" search. Inquiry terms used included; "police officer," "prison officer," "bung," "cop," and "screw."

The email evidence came at the trial of Webster, three other senior staff from the Sun, an army officer and his wife all of whom are facing charges related to alleged payments to public officials for confidential information, including details of Princes William and Harry's time at Sandhurst military academy.

After defence counsel formally closed their case the presiding judge, Mr Justice Saunders gave the jury legal directions on how they should look at the evidence they have heard over the last eight weeks. He began by telling them to disregard some of the testimony given by the former SAS soldier and best-selling author known as "Andy McNab," as he had expressed his opinion on how "serious" the selling of information was and this was not allowed in evidence. "I should have stopped him," the judge said.

Saunders also gave the jury instructions about how they should deal with the defendants' argument that what they published was in the "public interest." The judge said that the public interest standard was not met simply by "printing something the public were interested in, and instead had to be either a matter that the public ought to know about or would stimulate useful debate on a matter of public concern.

While the press, the judge said, was "an important part of our democracy,” he added "It is not above the law." He also said that it was clear that some of the information published was about people's private lives and the jury would have to consider if their right to privacy was outweighed by the public interest.

In the dock alongside Webster are Sun Royal editor Duncan Larcombe, deputy editor Geoffrey Webster, executive editor Fergus Shanahan, chief reporter John Kay, former army officer John Hardy and his wife Claire. Closing speeches are expected to occupy the rest of the week with the judge summing up the case next Monday.

All of the defendants deny all of the charges, the trial continues.

Download the full report:

Download report

Queries: campaign@hackinginquiry.org

related Posts

When media abuse of academics becomes the norm in HE
Following the death of Jason Arday, Corinne Fowler writes on the toll of media abuse on academics and what universities must do to protect their staff.
8/19/26
News
Reporting montage
Professor Arday, IPSO, and the press: steps to end the cycle of tragedy
Guest blog: Professor Paul Wragg, Professor of Media Law at the University of Leeds, on why the press hounding of Professor Jason Arday will happen again unless politicians act.
8/16/26
News
IPSO ties itself in knots over Telegraph complaint
Media lawyer Jonathan Coad complained to IPSO about a Telegraph article claiming Hacked Off wants "state control" of the press. IPSO's response contradicted itself within the space of a few paragraphs.
8/14/26
News
The letter the Guardian didn't publish: Tulisa Contostavlos interview
Hacked Off CEO Nathan Sparkes wrote to the Guardian to correct claims about press regulation in its interview with Tulisa Contostavlos. The paper didn't publish it — so we are.
8/12/26
News