News

HMRC leak trial - press officer was in charge of media for "law enforcement desk"

04/11/2014

Hacked Off

Newspaper
✕ Press claim

✓ The truth

Reach
Up to
people misled
Help us fight back

Join 71,384 others who are taking action to share the truth & raise standards in the press

1. Share the truth
Post this rebuttal on social media
2. Fund the fightback
Help us challenge more stories like this
Donate
3. Tell your MP
Send a ready-written email in 30 seconds
Email your MP

The head of news at Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs told an Old Bailey jury today that a civil servant accused of selling information to The Sun newspaper was in charge of media relations at the HMRC’s "law enforcement desk." Paul Franklin said that his department would sometimes give stories exclusively to selected journalists "who had shown a particular interest in a subject" but this should never be done "for personal gain."

On trial is Clodagh Hartley, a political correspondent for The Sun and Marta Bukarewicz the partner of former HMRC press officer Jonathan Hall. Both are accused of conspiring with Hall to "commit misconduct in a public office" over payments by The Sun for a series of stories the prosecution say were illegally leaked by Hall. The stories included a 2010 piece which revealed that the government was about to raise fuel duty before then then chancellor had given his budget speech in the House of Commons.

Further articles shown to the HMRC head of news included one about the 2010 emergency budget by George Osborne entitled "you ain't seen cutting yet" which revealed details of the coalition’s plans to lower the deficit by spending cuts to the prison service, police and transport services and "1 in 10 get axe" about reductions in public sector staff numbers. The witness told the court that these kind of leaks could be damaging as, in his view, such information should be released "in a structured way" so as all departments involved could be prepared for queries from staff and the media about the issue."

If government is to work properly information must be given at the appropriate time" the civil servant told the court and unauthorised leaks could lead to "huge distress to staff and to taxpayers."

Both of the defendants deny the charges the trial continues.

Hacked Off is funded by supporters, not newspaper owners. Help us take this to Parliament: give £10 a month.

Give £10 a month

Download the full report:

Download report

Queries: campaign@hackinginquiry.org

related Posts

Coverage of Professor Arday was not legitimate: the letter The Times refused to publish
Guest blog: Professor Paul Wragg replies to the letter published in The Times on 25 August defending the press coverage of Professor Jason Arday. The Times declined to publish his reply. We publish it here in full.
8/28/26
News
Defensive, evasive & hypocritical: The press reaction to the death of Jason Arday
The reaction of national newspapers to the death of Professor Jason Arday has exposed a brittle defensiveness at the heart of the press, and a determination to remain outside any meaningful accountability.
8/26/26
News
When media abuse of academics becomes the norm in HE
Following the death of Jason Arday, Corinne Fowler writes on the toll of media abuse on academics and what universities must do to protect their staff.
8/19/26
News
IPSO ties itself in knots over Telegraph complaint
Media lawyer Jonathan Coad complained to IPSO about a Telegraph article claiming Hacked Off wants "state control" of the press. IPSO's response contradicted itself within the space of a few paragraphs.
8/14/26
News